Commensurability (economics)

Commensurability in economics arises whenever there is a common measure through which the value of two entities can be compared.

Commensurability has two versions:

• Strong commensurability arises when it is possible to give cardinal values to entities as a consequence of utilising a given property measure entities. Thus we can say "This is two and a half times more valuable than that." This implies value monism.^[1]
• Weak commensurability arises when it is only possible to apply ordinal values to entities as a consequence of utilising a given property to rank entities, i.e., it is sufficient to say "This is more valuable than that." This is consistent with value-pluralism.^[1]

While weak commensurability is a form of strong comparability, it is distinct from weak comparability, where the fact that a comparison is valid in one context does not imply that it is so in all contexts. Also issues of comparability are different from indeterminacy: it may not be possible in certain circumstances to make a measurement, even though if such data was available it would be valid to compare measurements.^[1]

Commensurability is a key factor in the Socialist calculation debate.

References

1. O'Neill, John (1993). Ecology Policy and Politics: Human well-being and the natural world. London: Routledge. p. 102-106.