Heliograph

Fig. 1: Signaling with a Mance heliograph, 1910

A heliograph (Greek: Ἥλιος helios, meaning "sun", and γραφειν graphein, meaning "write") is a wireless solar telegraph that signals by flashes of sunlight (generally using Morse code) reflected by a mirror. The flashes are produced by momentarily pivoting the mirror, or by interrupting the beam with a shutter.^[1] The heliograph was a simple but effective instrument for instantaneous optical communication over long distances during the late 19th and early 20th century.^[1] Its main uses were military, survey and forest protection work. Heliographs were standard issue in the British and Australian armies until the 1960s, and were used by the Pakistani army as late as 1975.^[2]

Description

Fig. 2: German heliograph made by R. Fuess in Berlin (on display at the Museum of Communication in Frankfurt)

There were many heliograph types. Most heliographs were variants of the British Army Mance Mark V version (Fig.1). It used a mirror with a small unsilvered spot in the centre. The sender aligned the heliograph to the target by looking at the reflected target in the mirror and moving his head until the target was hidden by the unsilvered spot. Keeping his head still, he then adjusted the aiming rod so its cross wires bisected the target.^[3] He then turned up the sighting vane, which covered the cross wires with a diagram of a cross, and aligned the mirror with the tangent and elevation screws so the small shadow that was the reflection of the unsilvered spot hole was on the cross target.^[3] This indicated that the sunbeam was pointing at the target. The flashes were produced by a keying mechanism that tilted the mirror up a few degrees at the push of a lever at the back of the instrument. If the sun was in front of the sender, its rays were reflected directly from this mirror to the receiving station. If the sun was behind the sender, the sighting rod was replaced by a second mirror, to capture the sunlight from the main mirror and reflect it to the receiving station.^[4][5] The U. S. Signal Corps heliograph mirror did not tilt. This type produced flashes by a shutter mounted on a second tripod (Fig 4).^[4]

The heliograph had some great advantages. It allowed long distance communication without a fixed infrastructure, though it could also be linked to make a fixed network extending for hundreds of miles, as in the fort-to-fort network used for the Geronimo campaign. It was very portable, did not require any power source, and was relatively secure since it was invisible to those not near the axis of operation, and the beam was very narrow, spreading only 50 feet per mile of range. However, anyone in the beam with the correct knowledge could intercept signals without being detected.^[2][6] In the Boer War, where both sides used heliographs, tubes were sometimes used to decrease the dispersion of the beam.^[2] In some other circumstances, though, a narrow beam made it difficult to stay aligned with a moving target, as when communicating from shore to a moving ship, so the British issued a dispersing lens to broaden the heliograph beam from its natural diameter of 0.5 degrees to 15 degrees.^[7]

The distance that heliograph signals could be seen depended on the clarity of the sky and the size of the mirrors used. A clear line of sight was required, and since the Earth's surface is curved, the highest convenient points were used. Under ordinary conditions, a flash could be seen 30 miles (48 km) with the naked eye, and much farther with a telescope. The maximum range was considered to be 10 miles for each inch of mirror diameter. Mirrors ranged from 1.5 inches to 12 inches or more. The record distance was established by a detachment of U.S. signal sergeants by the inter-operation of stations on Mount Ellen, Utah, and Mount Uncompahgre, Colorado, 183 miles (295 km) apart on September 17, 1894, with Signal Corps heliographs carrying mirrors only 8 inches square.^[8]

History

Fig. 3 Ottoman heliograph crew at Huj during World War I, 1917

The German professor Carl Friedrich Gauss of the University of Göttingen developed and used a predecessor of the heliograph (the heliotrope) in 1821.^[1][9] His device directed a controlled beam of sunlight to a distant station to be used as a marker for geodetic survey work, and was suggested as a means of telegraphic communications.^[10] This is the first reliably documented heliographic device,^[11] despite much speculation about possible ancient incidents of sun-flash signalling, and the documented existence of other forms of ancient optical telegraphy.

For example, one author in 1919 chose to "hazard the theory"^[12] that the mainland signals Roman emperor Tiberius watched for from Capri^[13] were mirror flashes, but admitted "there are no references in ancient writings to the use of signaling by mirrors", and that the documented means of ancient long-range visual telecommunications was by beacon fires and beacon smoke, not mirrors.

Similarly, the story that a shield was used as a heliograph at the Battle of Marathon is a modern myth,^[14] originating in the 1800s. Herodotus never mentioned any flash.^[15] What Herodotus did write was that someone was accused of having arranged to "hold up a shield as a signal".^[16] Suspicion grew in the 1900s that the flash theory was implausible.^[17] The conclusion after testing the theory was "Nobody flashed a shield at the Battle of Marathon".^[18]

In a letter dated 3 June 1778, John Norris, High Sheriff of Buckinghamshire, England, notes: "Did this day heliograph intelligence from Dr [Benjamin] Franklin in Paris to Wycombe".^[19] However there is little evidence that "heliograph" here is other than a misspelling of "holograph". The term "heliograph" for solar telegraphy did not enter the English language until the 1870s - even the word "telegraphy" was not coined until the 1790s.

Henry Christopher Mance (1840–1926), of the British Government Persian Gulf Telegraph Department, developed the first widely accepted heliograph about 1869^[1][20][21] while stationed at Karachi, in the Bombay Presidency in British India. Mance was familiar with heliotropes by their use for the Great India Survey.^[8] The Mance Heliograph was operated easily by one man, and since it weighed about seven pounds, the operator could readily carry the device and its tripod. The British Army tested the heliograph in India at a range of 35 miles with favorable results.^[22] During the Jowaki Afridi expedition sent by the British-Indian government in 1877, the heliograph was first tested in war.^[23][24]

Fig. 4: US Signal Service heliograph, 1898

The simple and effective instrument that Mance invented was to be an important part of military communications for more than 60 years. The usefulness of heliographs was limited to daytimes with strong sunlight, but they were the most powerful type of visual signalling device known. In pre-radio times heliography was often the only means of communication that could span ranges of as much as 100 miles with a lightweight portable instrument.^[8]

In the United States military, by January 1880, Colonel Nelson A. Miles had established a line of heliographs connecting Fort Keogh and Fort Custer, Montana, a distance of 140 miles.^[25] In 1890, Major W. J. Volkmar of the US Army, demonstrated in Arizona and New Mexico the possibility of performing communication by heliograph over a heliograph network aggregating 2,000 miles in length.^[26] The network of communication begun by General Miles in 1886, and continued by Lieutenant W. A. Glassford, was perfected in 1889 at ranges of 85, 88, 95, and 125 miles over a rugged and broken country, which was the stronghold of the Apache and other hostile Indian tribes.^[8]

By 1887, heliographs in use included not only the British Mance and Begbie heliographs, but also the American Grugan, Garner and Pursell heliographs. The Grugan and Pursell heliographs used shutters, and the others used movable mirrors operated by a finger key. The Mance, Grugam and Pursell heliographs used two tripods, and the others one. The signals could either be momentary flashes, or momentary obscurations.^[27] In 1888, the US Signal Service reviewed all of these devices, as well as the Finley Helio-Telegraph,^[27] and finding none completely suitable, developed the US Signal Service heliograph, a two-tripod, shutter-based machine of 13 7/8 lb. total weight, and ordered 100 for a total cost of $4,205.^[28] In 1893, the number of heliographs manufactured for the US Signal Service was 133.^[29]

The heyday of the heliograph was probably the Second Boer War in South Africa, where it was much used by both the British and the Boers.^[1][2] The terrain and climate, as well as the nature of the campaign, made heliography a logical choice. For night communications, the British used some large Aldis lamps, brought inland on railroad cars, and equipped with leaf-type shutters for keying a beam of light into dots and dashes. During the early stages of the war, the British garrisons were besieged in Kimberley, Ladysmith, and Mafeking. With land telegraph lines cut, the only contact with the outside world was via light-beam communication, helio by day, and Aldis lamps at night.^[8]

In 1909, the use of heliography for forestry protection was introduced in the United States. By 1920 such use was widespread in the US and beginning in Canada, and the heliograph was regarded as "next to the telephone, the most useful communication device that is at present available for forest-protection services".^[4] D.P. Godwin of the US Forestry Service invented a very portable (4.5 lb) heliograph of the single-tripod, shutter plus mirror type for forestry use.^[4]

Immediately prior to the outbreak of World War I, the cavalry regiments of the Russian Imperial Army were still being trained in heliograph communications to augment the efficiency of their scouting and reporting roles.^[30] The Red Army during the Russian Civil War made use of a series of heliograph stations to disseminate intelligence efficiently about basmachi rebel movements in Turkestan in 1926.^[31]

During World War II, South African and Australian forces used the heliograph against German forces in Libya and Egypt in 1941 and 1942.^[1]

The heliograph remained standard equipment for military signallers in the Australian and British armies until the 1960s, where it was considered a "low probability of intercept" type of communication. The Canadian Army was the last major army to have the heliograph as an issue item. By the time the mirror instruments were retired, they were seldom used for signalling.^[8] However, as recently as the 1980s, heliographs were used by Afghan forces during the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan.^[1] Signal mirrors are still included in survival kits for emergency signaling to search and rescue aircraft.^[1]

Automated heliographs

Most heliographs of the 19th and 20th century were completely manual.^[4] The steps of aligning the heliograph on the target, co-aligning the reflected sunbeam with the heliograph, maintaining the sunbeam alignment as the sun moved, transcribing the message into flashes, modulating the sunbeam into those flashes, detecting the flashes at the receiving end, and transcribing the flashes into the message, were all manual steps.^[4] One notable exception – many French heliographs used clockwork heliostats to automatically steer out the sun's motion. By 1884, all active units of the "Mangin apparatus" (a dual-mode French military field optical telegraph that could use either lantern or sunlight) were equipped with clockwork heliostats.^[32] The Mangin apparatus with heliostat was still in service in 1917.^[33][34][35] Proposals to automate both the modulation of the sunbeam (by clockwork) and the detection (by electrical selenium photodetectors, or photographic means) date back to at least 1882.^[36] In 1961, the US Air Force was working on a space heliograph to signal between satellites^[37]

In May 2012, "Solar Beacon" robotic mirrors designed at UC Berkeley were mounted on the towers of the Golden Gate bridge, and a web site set up^[38] where the public could schedule times for the mirrors to signal with sun-flashes, entering the time and their latitude, longitude and altitude.^[39] The solar beacons were later moved to Sather Tower at UC Berkeley.^[40][41] By June 2012, the public could specify a "custom show" of up to 32 "on" or "off" periods of 4 seconds each, permitting the transmission of a few characters of Morse Code.^[42] The designer described the Solar Beacon as a "heliostat", not a "heliograph".^[39]

The first digitally controlled heliograph was designed and built in 2015.^[43][44] It was a semi-finalist in the Broadcom MASTERS competition.^[45]

Heliographs in fiction

• Rudyard Kipling's humorous poem "A Code of Morals" describes a fictional interception of a heliograph signal in 19th-century India.^[6]
• In Enid Blyton's sixth novel in her Famous Five series, Five on Kirrin Island Again (1947), Quentin, George's scientist father and the uncle of Julian, Dick and Anne uses heliography to signal to his family from Kirrin Island where he is conducting experiments.
• In the book The War of the Worlds by H. G. Wells (1898), heliographs are used to convey information about the invading Martians.^[46]
• The short story "The Attack on the Mountain" by Glendon Swarthout, in The Saturday Evening Post, July 4, 1959, described the use of the heliograph in the American West.^[47]
• The 2004 Western novel The Sergeant's Lady by Miles Hood Swarthout is set against the background of the heliograph network used in the U.S. Army campaign against the Apache Indians.^[47]
• In the 2010 science fiction novel Terminal World by Alastair Reynolds, the faction of people known as 'Swarm' use heliographs as communication between airships.
• In Robert Penn Warren's All the King's Men, a heliograph serves as an important image and appears early—on the second page of the novel.
• In Agatha Christie's 1947 novel The Labours of Hercules from the short story "The Erymanthian Boar" detective Hercule Poirot uses a heliograph to communicate from the top of Rochers Neiges where he is trapped to the police at the mountain's base.
• In Larry Niven's Ringworld series, revealed in The Ringworld Throne, the Ghoul species use heliographs for their vast communication network across the Ringworld.
• Also, Niven's book The Smoke Ring, the Admiralty Navy uses heliographs to communicate with its rocket ships.
• In the role-playing game Space: 1889, the Great Powers communicate with their colonial possessions on the inner planets of the Solar System by means of "orbiting heliograph stations".
• In The Adventures of Tintin comic The Red Sea Sharks, the US.. Navy communicates by heliograph to antagonist Rastapopoulos aboard a passenger liner. Tintin had earlier signalled the same liner while shipwrecked using a hand mirror.
• In "Cast Away", Chuck Nolan (Tom Hanks) uses a makeshift heliograph to try to signal a passing ship from his island in Morse Code, shouting the code as he signaled the code, "SOS."
• In the television series Lost, Benjamin Linus signals his people using a heliograph in the episode "There's No Place Like Home (Part 1)".
• In the Agatha Christie novel And Then There Were None, Lombard suggests creating a heliograph to contact the mainland.
• The books Matter and Feersum Endjinn by Iain M. Banks both feature several instances of heliographic communication.
• The Realm, the central empire in the world of the roleplaying game Exalted, possesses an elaborate heliograph network.
• In the 2010 film, How I Ended This Summer, set at an old meteorological station on a remote island in the Arctic, a heliograph is used to send data.

See also

• Heliotrope (instrument)
• Semaphore line
• Signal lamp
• Telegraph hill
• Heliography, an early photographic process invented by Joseph Nicéphore Niépce around 1822

References

1. Woods, Daniel (2008). "Heliograph and Mirrors". In Sterling, Christopher. Military Communications: From Ancient Times to the 21st Century. ABC-CLIO. p. 208. ISBN 1851097325.
2. Major J. D. Harris WIRE AT WAR - Signals communication in the South African War 1899–1902. Retrieved on 1 June 2008. Discussion of heliograph use in the Boer War.
3. Signal Training. III. Pamphlet No. 2. Heliograph, 5-inch, Mark V. 1922. London: His Majesty's Stationery Office. 1922. pp. 10–13.
4. W. N. Millar (1920), Canadian Forestry Service. Methods of Communication Adapted to Forest Protection Google Books. Retrieved on 1 June 2008. pp. 160-181 are devoted to the heliograph, with diagrams of the British, American, and Godwin type.
5. Manual Of Instruction In Army Signaling 1886 Section III- Apparatus And Method Of Using It. Retrieved on 1 June 2008. Diagrams and instructions for British military heliograph (note British heraldry on cover).
6. Kipling, Rudyard A Code of Morals. The Kipling Society website. Retrieved on 1 June 2008.
7. Signals, Royal. "The Heliograph". Signalling Handbook (1905). Retrieved 15 April 2012.
8. Coe, Lewis The Telegraph: A History of Morse's Invention and Its Predecessors in the United States. Google Books. Retrieved on 1 June 2008.
9. Dunnington, G. Waldo (2004). Carl Friedrich Gauss: Titan of Science. New York: The Mathematical Association of America. pp. 122–127. ISBN 0-88385-547-X.
10. "The Heliotrope". The Manchester Iris. 1 (32): 255–256. September 7, 1822. Retrieved 18 November 2012.
11. Holzmann, Gerard (1995). Björn Pehrson, ed. The early history of data networks. p. 10. ISBN 0818667826. Retrieved 18 November 2012.
12. Kingman, John (September 1919). "The Isle of Capri: An Imperial Residence and Probable Wireless Station of Ancient Rome". The National Geographic Magazine. p. 224. Retrieved 18 November 2012.
13. Suetonius (1796). The Lives of the First Twelve Caesars. G.G. and J. Robinson, Paternoster-Row. p. 296.
14. Krentz, Peter (2010). The Battle of Marathon. Yale University. p. 160. ISBN 0300120850.
15. Sekunda, Nicholas (2002). Marathon 490 BC: The First Persian Invasion Of Greece. Osprey Publishing. p. 73. ISBN 1841760005.
16. Herodotus (1920). "6.115.1, 6.121.1, 6.123.1,6.124,2". Herodotus, The Histories, with an English translation by A. D. Godley. Harvard University Press.
17. Reynolds, P. K. Baillie (1929). "The Shield Signal at the Battle of Marathon". The Journal of Hellenic Studies. 49 (Part I). JSTOR 625005.
18. Hodge, A. Trevor (2001). "Reflections on the Shield at Marathon". The Annual of the British School at Athens. 96: 237–259. doi:10.1017/s0068245400005281. JSTOR 30073279.
19. Deacon, Richard (1978). The Silent War: a History of Western Naval Intelligence. David & Charles. p. 21. ISBN 978-0715375570.
20. Mance, Henry (10 February 1872). "The Heliograph or Sun Telegraph". United Service Institution of India. 1 (5): 123–130. Retrieved 16 June 2013.
21. Goode, Samuel (June 14, 1875). "Mance's Heliograph, or Sun-Telegraph". Journal of the Royal United Service Institution. XIX (LXXXIII): 534–548. doi:10.1080/03071847509415772. Retrieved 2011-06-21.
22. Luck, George (1872-05-24). "Army Signalling, Heliograph". United Service Institution of India. 2 (7): 101–105.
23. Wynne, Major A.S. (March 15, 1880). "Heliography and Army Signalling Generally". Journal of the Royal United Service Institution. XXIV (CV): 235–258. doi:10.1080/03071848009417153. Retrieved June 21, 2011.
24. R. W. Burns (2004) Communications: An International History of the Formative Years. Google Books. Retrieved on 2 June 2008. pp. 192-196 discuss the heliograph.
25. Reade, Lt. Philip (January 1880). "About Heliographs". The United Service. 2: 91–108. Retrieved June 21, 2011.
26. Greely, Adolphus (August 1899). "The Evolution of the Signal Corps". Ainslee's Magazine. IV (1): 17. Retrieved 1 September 2014.
27. An Improved Method in the Art of Signalling for Military and Scientific Purposes, The American Helio-Telegraph and Signal Light Company, 1887, retrieved 1 June 2008.
28. Annual Report of the Chief Signal Officer of the Army to the Secretary of War, Google Books, 1889, pp. 43–7, retrieved 3 June 2008.
29. Report of the Chief Signal Officer. U.S. G.P.O. 1893. p. 671.
30. Littauer, Vladimir. Russian Hussar. p. 123. ISBN 1-59048-256-5.
31. Everett-Heath, Tom, Central Asia: Aspects of Transition, p. 20, retrieved 3 June 2008.
32. Ternant, A.-L. (1884). Les télégraphes (2nd ed.). Hachette. pp. 35–65.
33. Charles-La Vauzelle, Henri (1912). Instruction Pratique Sur L'Installation des Communications Optiques dans le Service De la Telegraphie Militaire: Premiere Partie, Communications Optiques de Campagne. pp. 30–32, 42–43.
34. BOUCHETHAL, J.L. (1916). "LA TÉLÉGRAPHIE OPTIQUE AUX ARMÉES". La Science et La Vie (28): 337–342.
35. "Ottoman Soldiers Mounting Signal Apparatus, 1917". Flickr. Ottoman Imperial Archives. Retrieved 7 September 2015.
36. "The Heliograph in Mauritius". Engineering. 34: 363. October 13, 1882.
37. Pursglove, S. David (1961). "Ancient Heliograph Goes Modern for Space Age". Science and Mechanics: 70. Archived from the original on May 25, 2011.
38. "Solar Beacon". Archived from the original on May 30, 2012. Retrieved 30 May 2012.
39. Boxall, Bettina. "Golden Gate Bridge is prepared for 75th birthday celebration". LA Now. Los Angeles Times.
40. Tuan, Lydia (10 September 2013). "Solar Beacon atop Campanile allows for safe observation of sunlight". The Daily Californian.
41. "Solar Beacon". Retrieved 7 September 2015.
42. Vallerga, John. "Custom Show Setting". Solar Beacon. Retrieved 28 June 2012.
43. "IPA Freshmans science fair project". Island Pacific Academy. Retrieved 6 September 2015.
44. Welch, Natalie. "Digital Heliograph". Retrieved 6 September 2015.
45. "2015 Broadcom MASTERS Semifinalists". Retrieved 5 September 2015.
46. H. G. Wells The War of the Worlds, Chapter 13. Retrieved on June 1, 2008.
47. Miles Hood Swarthout The Sergeant's Lady. Google Books. Retrieved on 1 June 2008.

• Great Days of the Heliograph by Lewis Coe

External links

• Heliography: Communicating with Mirrors Photographs of British, American and Portuguese heliographs.
• The Heliograph A description of the British Mance, Begbie and French LeSeurre heliographs with illustrations (1899)
• Eliografo Detailed color photographs of a World War 2 British Mance heliograph (Italian).
• "Heliograph" at the National Library of Australia: Trove; 100+ historical heliograph photographs at the Australian War Memorial and elsewhere
• Royal Signals Datasheet No. 2. The Heliograph (revised April 2003)
• CHAPTER IV THE HELIOGRAPH (PAGE 48 OF THE 1905 SIGNALLING HANDBOOK)
• Mance Mark V Heliograph Detailed photos of a British Mark V Heliograph and kit, links to patents. Clicking on visible photos reveals high resolution photos.
• The Heliograph in the Apache Wars
• Signals communication in the South African War 1899-1902