Matthew Feldman

Matthew Feldman
Campaign brochure published by Citizens for Feldman, Teaneck, N.J., 1973.
New Jersey State Senator
In office January 1966 – January 1978
Preceded by	Pierce H. Deamer, Jr.
Succeeded by	Joseph C. Woodcock, Jr.
New Jersey State Senator
In office January 1974 – January 1994
Preceded by	Joseph C. Woodcock, Jr.
Succeeded by	Byron Baer
Senate President
In office January 1976 – January 1978
Preceded by	Frank J. Dodd
Succeeded by	Joseph P. Merlino
New Jersey Senate Majority Leader
In office January 1974 – January 1976
Preceded by	Alfred D. Schiaffo
Succeeded by	Joseph P. Merlino
Mayor of Teaneck
In office February 1959 – January 1966
Preceded by	August Hanniball Jr.
Succeeded by	Thomas J. Costa
Personal details
Born	Matthew Feldman March 22, 1919 Jersey City, New Jersey, U.S.
Died	April 11, 1994 (aged 75) Teaneck, New Jersey, U.S.
Political party	Democratic
Spouse(s)	Muriel Gunsberg Feldman
Religion	Judaism

Matthew Feldman (March 22, 1919 – April 11, 1994)^[1] was an American Democratic Party politician who served as a New Jersey State Senator and Mayor of Teaneck, New Jersey. As Mayor of Teaneck in the early 1960s, he achieved racial and political harmony during integration of its schools and neighborhoods. He served as the President of the New Jersey State Senate.

Early life

Feldman was born March 22, 1919 in Jersey City, New Jersey, the son of Samuel and Mary Feldman, both immigrants from Poland. He had an older brother, Norman, and a younger brother, Melvin. He excelled in basketball and boxing, and joined the boxing team at the University of North Carolina. He used his physical prowess to "bust up" pro-Nazi German American Bund rallies held in North Bergen in the late 1930s, acting as a "heckler, protester, and street fighter."^[2]

He served as a U.S. Air Force Captain during World War II, and later served as New Jersey State Commander of the Jewish War Veterans. He later attended Panzer College. He moved to Teaneck in 1947 after marrying Muriel Gunsberg.^[3] Feldman joined the Federal Wine and Liquor Company, a liquor distribution business started by his father and uncle.

Leon Sokol, a New Jersey lawyer who was a longtime friend of Feldman, says that in 1946, Feldman was driving along Route 17 with his family on their way to the Catskills when he spotted a sign for new housing in Ridgewood. It read 'Restricted Development' – code for no Jews or blacks. Feldman was so furious that he stopped the car, called some veteran friends and staged the forerunner of a 'flash' protest. His wife, Muriel, was furious, his kids screaming in the car." ^[4]

Mayor of Teaneck

In 1958, he was elected to the Teaneck Township Council, and was re-elected in 1962 with over 75% of the vote. In February 1959, Feldman became the Mayor of Teaneck following the death of Mayor August Hanniball Jr.. He served as Mayor until 1966.

Teaneck has non-partisan local elections, and Feldman was an independent when he won in 1958. He says he was courted by Bergen County Republicans, who viewed him as a "New Jersey Jacob Javits. Feldman told a New York Times reporter in 1972 that GOP leaders told him he could be a Senator or a Congressman someday, and that he held them off as he explored his political identity. "Then Kennedy came into town in 1960. He electrified me. It was that that made me go into partisan politics. I felt you had to be a Democrat. Nothing else made sense."^[5]

Columnist Charles Stile of The Record wrote that Feldman's "awakening occurred just as Teaneck threatened to become racial tinderbox over a plan to integrate the Teaneck public schools – a plan advanced by the pioneering Superintendent of Schools Harvey Scribner, which created a new, central-sixth Bryant School in the predominantly black northeast section of Teaneck. It involved busing some students, which sparked the uproar."^[6]

Officially, Mayor Feldman and the rest of the Teaneck Council remained neutral, citing a separation of powers between the municipal government and the elected Board of Education. In September, 1964, Feldman was interviewed on WJRZ Radio following threats of boycotting the opening day of school and of violence. Feldman told listeners: "But I appeal to you, I urge you not to use 11- and 12-year-old children as weapons in a conflict between adults. Do not confuse your children by telling them that the obedience of law and authority is essential and then telling them that they don't have to attend school even though the law requires them to do so."^[7] School opened with no violence or large protests.

New Jersey State Senator

The U.S. Supreme Court, in Reynolds v. Sims (more commonly known as One Man, One Vote), required redistricting by state legislatures for congressional districts to keep represented populations equal, as well as requiring both houses of state legislatures to have districts drawn that contained roughly equal populations, and to perform redistricting when needed.^[8] Because of its population, Bergen County went from one Senate seat to four. Feldman became one of the four Democratic State Senate candidates, running on the Democratic organization ticket with Ned Parsekian, Jeremiah F. O'Connor, and Alfred Kiefer. In the Democratic Primary, the four easily defeated two other candidates, Jeanette L. Winslow and Allan L. Fletcher.^[9]

Feldman's campaign was aided by the presence of popular Democratic Governor Richard J. Hughes at the top of the ticket, and by a major division among Bergen County Republicans that led to incumbent GOP Senator Pierce H. Deamer Jr. being dumped from the organization line. The Bergen County Republican Organization backed Assembly Speaker Marion West Higgins, Assemblyman Peter Moraites, and former Assemblymen Nelson G. Gross and Arthur Vervaet. Deamer ran on an insurgent ticket with Assemblymen Richard Vander Plaat and Harry Randall, Jr., and former Assemblyman Carmine Savino.^[10] The organization slate won decisively.^[11]

In the General Election, Democrats won all four Bergen County Senate seats. Feldman ran second of the four, and out polled the leading Republican votegetter by more than 11,000 votes.^[12]

During his first term in the State Senate, he served as the Assistant Majority Leader and as Chairman of the Senate Education Committee. Feldman led the fight to establish the Department of Higher Education and for increases in state education funding at all levels. He sponsored legislation that created the New Jersey Motion Picture and Television Development Commission.^[13]

In 1967, Feldman was a candidate for re-election to a second term in the State Senate. Yet another round of redistricting gave Bergen County a fifth Senate seat, and incumbents Feldman, Parsekian, O'Connor and Kiefer ran with Cliffside Park Mayor Gerald Calabrese. They easily defeated I. Richard Lapidus, a Physics professor at the Stevens Institute of Technology, in the primary election.^[14]

In a Republican political year (the mid-term of Governor Hughes's second term), Republicans Fairleigh Dickinson, Jr., Joseph C. Woodcock Jr., Alfred D. Schiaffo, Garrett W. Hagedorn, and Willard B. Knowlton won all five Bergen County State Senate seats by a wide margin. Feldman ran seventh, finishing more than 53,000 votes behind the fifth place Republican.^[15]

After leaving the Senate, Feldman was elected Bergen County Democratic Chairman in 1968. He held that post until 1973.

New Jersey faced another round of redistricting for the 1973 elections, for the first time creating districts with one Senator and two members of the State Assembly. Teaneck was placed in the new 37th district, along with other Democratic-leaning towns. Feldman ran again for the Senate, with incumbent Assemblymen Albert Burstein and Byron Baer running with him. In the General Election, he faced a rematch with Woodcock and won by 11,166 votes, 36,690 (58.62%) to 25,524 (40.78%).^[16] The 1973 election, held less than two weeks after President Richard M. Nixon fired Watergate Special Prosecutor Archibald Cox in the Saturday Night Massacre, was a landslide year for New Jersey Democrats. Brendan T. Byrne was elected Governor by more than 700,000 votes, and Democrats captured a 29-10 majority in the State Senate. Upon returning to the Senate, Feldman was elected Senate Majority Leader, a post he held in 1974 and 1975. In 1976 and 1977, Feldman was the Senate President. The incumbent Senate President, Frank J. Dodd, had hoped to keep the post, but Feldman received the support of a majority of Democratic Senators and Dodd withdrew as a candidate for the leadership post. Feldman ran with the support of Byrne, who was forced to back off a plan to allow crossover votes in primaries.^[17] At times when Byrne was out of state, Feldman served as Acting Governor.

State Income Tax

The New Jersey Supreme Court ruled in 1973 that school children in urban and rural areas of the state were being denied a “thorough and efficient education” because public schools were too reliant on local property taxes to fund education. The court ordered the state to come up with the money to fund urban and rural school districts to a level equal to the suburbs. Governor Byrne viewed the establishment of a State Income Tax as the only practical way of state government coming up with the money. Byrne also faced a July 1, 1976 court-imposed deadline to fund all schools or have all schools ordered closed. Byrne’s Income Tax legislation only narrowly passed the State Assembly. The 21 votes necessary to pass it in the Senate were not yet committed. All 120 New Jersey legislators were up for re-election in 1977 and worried that the tax would create a Republican landslide. Byrne turned to Feldman, a staunch political ally, and asked Feldman to lead the Income Tax negotiations. Refusing to allow Senators to leave the chamber, Feldman played a key role in passing the tax plan, albeit negotiating through the Bicentennial weekend and passing the package on July 8.^[18] By the following year, Byrne and Feldman were re-elected and Democrats held their majorities in the State Senate and General Assembly.

Liquor Scandal

On October 12, 1976, Senate President Feldman was indicted on federal bribery charges. Federal prosecutors had charged Feldman with bribing an employee of a restaurant chain to secure business for Federal Wine & Liquor, a liquor distribution company owned and operated by the Feldman family. Feldman's son was also charged. Both Feldman's appeared in federal court on October 19, 1976 and entered not guilty pleas. A third defendant, Donald Schwartz, who had been Vice President of Emerson's Ltd., pleaded guilty. Feldman was serving as Acting Governor on the date of his court appearance, as Byrne was traveling in Japan. Federal prosecutors said that Feldman paid $6,400 in cash to Schwartz in order to win about $240,000 in liquor business. Schwartz said one payment came in an envelope "bearing the New Jersey Senate seal."^[19]

Feldman unsuccessfully sought to have his indictment dismissed, claiming his prosecution by U.S. Attorney Jonathan Goldstein, a Republican and a Nixon appointee, was politically motivated. Feldman said such payments were common practice in the liquor distribution business. On November 26, 1976, Feldman changed his plea to guilty. Addressing U.S. District Court Judge Frederick Bernard Lacey, Feldman sought to differentiate between his actions as a businessman and his duties as a State Senator: "Matty Feldman, State Senator, never met with Schwartz. It was Matty Feldman, Vice President of Federal Wine and Liquor, who met with him."^[20]

There were some questions regarding Feldman's legal right to serve in the Senate. Commercial bribery is a federal misdemeanor, not a felony, but New Jersey state law says that anyone convicted of crimes of moral turpitude cannot serve in the Legislature. While serving as Acting Governor, Feldman had the same constitutional as the Governor, further complicating matters. Attorney General William Hyland deflected the question to the Senate, saying the Senate had the constitutional right to determine the qualifications of their own members.^[21]

On December 13, 1976, the Chief Counsel to the New Jersey Legislature, William M. Lanning, issued an opinion that Feldman's conviction on federal commercial bribery charges did not involve "fraudulent, dishonest or corrupt conduct," and could remain in the State Senate. Attorney General Hyland concurred with the opinion.^[22]

When the New Jersey Legislature met on January 10, 1977 for the opening of the legislative session, Republicans made an attempt to remove Feldman, but lost by a 24-10 vote. All Senate Republicans voted against Feldman, and five Democratic Senators did not vote at all.^[23]

In March 1977, a state Superior Court Judge refused to remove Feldman from office, saying he had no authority to override the Senate's decision. A lawsuit seeking Feldman's ouster had been filed by Wyckoff Councilman Henry McNamara, a Republican. (In 1985, McNamara would join Feldman in the State Senate.)^[24]

Senate Re-Election Campaign

Feldman announced in April 1977 that he would seek re-election to the Senate. He was unopposed in the Democratic Primary. In the General Election campaign, Republican William C. Clark, a former Bergenfield Councilman, hammered Feldman on his ethical issues, and on the "totality of his record. "Here's a man making laws in Trenton and breaking them in his business. It's incredible. It gives the state a black eye." Feldman called his actions a "misadventure and an error in judgment," and said the prosecution was just politics. He touted an endorsement from a former Republican Senator, Fairleigh Dickinson, Jr., who had unseated Feldman a decade earlier.^[25] Feldman won by 10,222 votes, 31,945 (58.98%) to 21,723 (40.11%),^[26] winning re-election by an even higher percentage than in the Democratic landslide of 1973.^[27]

Feldman was re-elected in 1981 with 62% against attorney Barbara L. deMare,^[28] with 64% against Bergen County Bar Association President Michael L. Kingman in 1983,^[29] and 67% against Shel Haas in 1987.^[30]

In 1990 Feldman helped steer through the Senate Jim Florio's transformation of state aid and teacher pensions after he arranged for Bergen County school districts to receive special transportation aid that districts in no other county were eligible for.

Feldman's last Senate campaign was in 1991, when he was 72 years old and dealing with some serious health issues. 1991 was a Republican landslide year after Governor James Florio sought a $2.8 billion tax increase—the largest increase of any state in U.S. history. T^[31] He faced a tough Republican challenger, 35-year-old Todd Caliguire, who had served as Assistant Counsel to Governor Thomas Kean. Feldman survived, narrowly, beating Caliguire by just 3,264 votes, 24,309 (53.60%) to 21,045 (46.40%).^[32]

Feldman was the Senate President Pro-Tempore from 1978 to 1982. He served as Chairman of the Senate Education Committee from 1978 to 1992. Feldman served in the majority for all but the final two years of his Senate career.

Bid for Bergen County Executive

Bergen County voters chose to change their form of county government in a 1985 referendum, creating a new post of County Executive. The first election would be in 1986. Feldman, whose 1976 bribery conviction effectively ended his hopes of running for Governor in 1981, surprised most political observers by announcing that he would run for Bergen County Executive. He faced no opposition in the Democratic Primary after his only rival, Freeholder Doris Mahalick, dropped out due to lack of organizational support and fundraising resources. Feldman was the favorite in the General Election against Republican William D. McDowell, the Bergen County Sheriff. Feldman criticized McDowell's management skills, citing a state audit that criticized fire-safety measures and medical procedures at the county jail run by McDowell. McDowell said Feldman had falsely claimed in campaign literature that he authored a 1966 Senate bill creating Bergen County Community College, noting that the college has been founded the year before Feldman was elected to the Senate.^[33] McDowell also touted an endorsement from Mahalick.^[34] While McDowell held to his promise not to raise Feldman's 1976 bribery conviction, Republican surrogates did it for him.^[35] McDowell beat Feldman by about 20,000 votes, 112,619 (55%) to 92,649 (45%).^[36]

Feldman suffered more than a political loss during the 1986 campaign: his 12-year-old grandson was killed in a car accident, and his brother and business partner, Norman Feldman, died. "A little piece of Matty died when the boy died," former Secretary of the Senate John J. McCarthy, told The Record in 1994.^[37]

Retirement and Death

On February 17, 1993, Feldman announced that he would not seek re-election to an eighth term in the Senate. In a letter to Democratic County Committee members, Feldman wrote: "For the Democratic Party to remain vital, it must continually redefine and renew itself. To do that, it must permit younger people to move up into positions of responsibility." Feldman told The Record "We've been agonizing over this for months. Th he family has insisted that I've given public service over 30 years. It's time to conclude that public service." He cited the election of Bill Clinton and Al Gore in 1992 as evidence of the importance of "passing the baton to a new generation."^[38]

Feldman's wife, Muriel, died on November 7, 1993. He continued to battle health issues after leaving the Senate in January, 1994, and he died on April 11, 1994 in Teaneck at the age of 75—four months after leaving the Senate.^[39]

Legacy

In a 2011 profile, columnist Charles Stile of The Record wrote: "Matthew Feldman was the master of New Jersey's Senate for nearly 30 years, a legislative broker of the old school. He deployed a shrewd, conciliatory style, relying more on persuasion than partisan attacks or campaign cash. Feldman was more inclined to grab a colleague with a warm bear hug than twist their arm."^[40]

The Advisory Board on Community Relations of the Township of Teaneck recognizes worthy individuals and organizations with the "Matthew Feldman Community Service Award", named in his honor.^[41][42]

Teaneck designated about 16 acres of the Roemer Woods as the Senator Matthew Feldman Nature Preserve.^[43]

References

1. Social Security Death Index via Ancestry.com.
2. Stile, Charles (2 October 2011). "Remembering state senator Matthew Feldman of Teaneck". The Record. Retrieved 31 December 2014.
3. Legislative Manual of New Jersey. Joseph J. Gribbons. 1980.
4. Stile, Charles (2 October 2011). "Remembering state senator Matthew Feldman of Teaneck". The Record. Retrieved 31 December 2014.
5. Ferretti, Fred (22 October 1972). "Bergen Politics: A Tale of 2 Men; Bergen Politics: A Tale of the Leaders of Two Major Parties". New York Times.
6. Stile, Charles (2 October 2011). "Remembering state senator Matthew Feldman of Teaneck". The Record. Retrieved 31 December 2014.
7. Stile, Charles (2 October 2011). "Remembering state senator Matthew Feldman of Teaneck". The Record. Retrieved 31 December 2014.
8. "JERSEY ORDERED TO REAPPORTION; Judge Finds Congressional Districts Unconstitutional". New York Times. 21 May 1965.
9. Our Campaigns http://www.ourcampaigns.com/RaceDetail.html?RaceID=750646. Retrieved 30 December 2014. Missing or empty |title= (help)
10. Waggoner, Walter H. (30 May 1965). "G.O.P. FIGHTS PACE JERSEY PRIMARIES; 3,146,000 Are Eligible to Vote on Tuesday". New York Times.
11. "Our Campaigns". Retrieved 3 December 2014.
12. Our Campaigns http://www.ourcampaigns.com/RaceDetail.html?RaceID=741444. Retrieved 30 December 2014. Missing or empty |title= (help)
13. New York Times obituary
14. Our Campaigns http://www.ourcampaigns.com/RaceDetail.html?RaceID=750572. Retrieved 30 December 2014. Missing or empty |title= (help)
15. Our Campaigns http://www.ourcampaigns.com/RaceDetail.html?RaceID=741563. Retrieved 30 December 2014. Missing or empty |title= (help)
16. Our Campaigns http://www.ourcampaigns.com/RaceDetail.html?RaceID=402221. Retrieved 30 December 2014. Missing or empty |title= (help)
17. "FELDMAN ELECTED SENATE PRESIDENT; Byrne Wins Leadership Fight, but Cost Is Called High LeFante Named Speaker". New York Times. 15 December 1976.
18. Stile, Charles (2 October 2011). "Remembering state senator Matthew Feldman of Teaneck". The Record. Retrieved 31 December 2014.
19. Waggoner, Walter H. (20 October 1976). "PLEA OF NOT GUILTY ENTERED BY FELDMAN; Senate Head, Charged With Bribe, Takes Over as Byrne Leaves Feldman Denies Guilt and Then Takes Over for Byrne". New York Times.
20. Waggoner, Walter H. (30 November 1976). "Jersey Legislator Guilty of Bribery On Liquor Supply; Feldman Pleads Guilty to Bribery of Liquor Buyer". New York Times.
21. Waggoner, Walter H. (30 November 1976). "Jersey Legislator Guilty of Bribery On Liquor Supply; Feldman Pleads Guilty to Bribery of Liquor Buyer". New York Times.
22. Sullivan, Joseph F. (14 December 1976). "Counsel for Legislature Clears Feldman to Stay in State Senate". New York Times.
23. Waldron, Martin (12 January 1977). "Trenton Strikes a Partisan Note As Feldman Heads Senate Again". New York Times.
24. Hanley, Robert (8 March 1977). "JUDGE REJECTS A BID TO REMOVE FELDMAN; Refuses to Oust President of Senate Over Plea on Bribery Charge". New York Times.
25. Hanley, Robert (7 October 1977). "Both Feldman and His Opponent Willingly Discuss Senator's Bribe". New York Times.
26. Our Campaigns http://www.ourcampaigns.com/RaceDetail.html?RaceID=396443. Retrieved 31 December 2014. Missing or empty |title= (help)
27. Narvaez, Alfonso. "Easy Triumph by Governor Helps Democrats Keep Trenton Control", The New York Times, November 9, 1977. Accessed August 18, 2008.
28. Our Campaigns http://www.ourcampaigns.com/RaceDetail.html?RaceID=269520. Retrieved 31 December 2014. Missing or empty |title= (help)
29. Our Campaigns http://www.ourcampaigns.com/RaceDetail.html?RaceID=274095. Retrieved 31 December 2014. Missing or empty |title= (help)
30. Our Campaigns http://www.ourcampaigns.com/RaceDetail.html?RaceID=52527. Retrieved 31 December 2014. Missing or empty |title= (help)
31. Attinger, Joelle. "New Jersey's Robin Hood", July 2, 1990; accessed August 7, 2007.
32. Our Campaigns http://www.ourcampaigns.com/RaceDetail.html?RaceID=15643. Retrieved 31 December 2014. Missing or empty |title= (help)
33. Hanley, Robert (30 October 1986). "THE POLITICAL CAMPAIGN; BERGEN, AFTER 271 YEARS, TO ELECT FIRST EXECUTIVE". New York Times. Retrieved 31 December 2014.
34. Sullivan, Joseph (12 October 1986). "POLITICS; BERGEN VOTING FOR MORE THAN EXECUTIVE". New York Times. Retrieved 31 December 2014.
35. Stile, Charles (2 October 2011). "Remembering state senator Matthew Feldman of Teaneck". The Record. Retrieved 31 December 2014.
36. Sullivan, Joseph F. (5 November 1986). "THE ELECTIONS: Changes in Jersey; Continuity in Connecticut; NEW JERSEY: Shapiro Loses in Essex County; McDowell Is Winner in Bergen". New York Times. Retrieved 31 December 2014.
37. Gilbert, Pat R.; Gibson, David (12 April 1994). "Longtime State Senator Matthew Feldman Dies". The Record. Retrieved 31 December 2014.
38. Blomquist, David (18 February 1993). The Record http://www.teaneck.org/virtualvillage/mayors/feldman/leavesenate.html. Retrieved 31 December 2014. Missing or empty |title= (help)
39. Ronald Sullivan (April 12, 1994). "Matthew Feldman, 75, Mayor Of Teaneck and State Senator". New York Times. Retrieved 2011-10-25. Matthew Feldman, a New Jersey Democratic legislative leader who served as Mayor of Teaneck and then for 22 years in the State Senate, died yesterday in Holy Name Hospital in Teaneck, N.J. He was 75. The Office of the Senate Democrats said he died of natural causes.
40. Stile, Charles (2 October 2011). "Remembering state senator Matthew Feldman of Teaneck". The Record. Retrieved 31 December 2014.
41. Teaneck Fire Department 2003, Township of Teaneck. Accessed June 4, 2007. "Also in the year 2002, Box 54 was the recipient of the prestigious Matthew Feldman Award, given by the Township of Teaneck to service organizations who are deserving of it."
42. Aberback, Brian. "Teaneck salutes group formed in slaying's wake", The Record (Bergen County), March 8, 2007. Accessed June 4, 2007.
43. O'Shea, Beverly (21 March 1990). "Feldman Preserve naming April 22". Teaneck Suburbinite. Retrieved 31 December 2014.