Schwartzberg's weighted voting

Schwartzberg’s weighted voting is a method of voting, proposed by Joseph E. Schwartzberg, for representation of nations in a reformed United Nations.

The formula is (P+C+M)/3, where P is the nation's percentage of the total population of all UN members, C is that nation's percentage of the total contributions to the UN budget, and M, the nation's percentage of the total UN membership (which of course would be the same for all members); divide that sum by 3 to get the average.

Under this method, the nations with the greatest voting power would be the U.S. (9.065%); China (7.672%); Japan (7.282%); and India (5.960%). This system avoids giving microstates disproportionate influence (as under one state, one vote) while also avoiding giving a coalition of populous developing countries such as China and India control over the UN, as might happen under one man, one vote.[1]

It is important in the calculation of C (Nation's contributions to the UN budget) that only actual paid contributions be counted rather than owed contributions in arrears, since some major nations are very significantly in arrears in their payment of their agreed level of United Nations dues.

See also

References

  1. ↑ Schwartzberg, Joseph E.. "Appendix 1". Revitalizing the United Nations : Reform Through Weighted Voting (PDF). New York and The Hague: Institute For Global Policy, World Federalist Movement. pp. 60–63. ISBN 0-9710727-4-4. OCLC 56124473. Retrieved 2005-12-14.



This article is issued from Wikipedia - version of the 1/27/2011. The text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share Alike but additional terms may apply for the media files.