Battle of Milk Creek

Battle of Milk Creek
Part of the White River War, American Indian Wars
Milk Creek Battlefield Park. The site of the battle was behind the park in the creek valley below.
Date September 29–October 5, 1879 Location 17 miles northeast of present-day Meeker, Colorado[1] Result United States victory
Belligerents
United States	Ute
Commanders and leaders
Wesley Merritt Thomas Tipton Thornburgh †	Ouray Nicaagat (Jack)
Strength
~700	~250
Casualties and losses
13 killed 44 wounded	19–37 killed 7 missing

The Battle of Milk Creek was an armed confrontation that began on September 29, 1879, in northwestern Colorado and coincided with the Meeker massacre. It lasted until October 5 as warriors of the White River Ute tribe besieged a United States Army detachment in one of the last true battles of the American Indian Wars.

Background

In the years preceding the Meeker massacre, the idealistic but ambitious and debt-ridden Nathan C. Meeker had taken the advice of friend and mentor Horace Greeley to go west, where he made an ill-fated attempt to establish Union Colony, a utopian socialistic community at the site of present-day Greeley, Colorado. Failing there, Meeker then secured a position as U.S. Indian Agent for the White River Indian Agency through political connections.

The Ute tribe, ensconced protectively in Colorado's Rocky Mountains, were among the last remaining Native American horse nomads. In the centuries since their arrival in the Americas, horses had become so crucial to the Utes' survival that they had gained a sort of totemic significance among the Utes. As a federal Indian agent, Nathan Meeker embarked upon a program to replace the Ute lifestyle of hunting bison from horseback with plowshares and seeds.

The Utes, attached to their horses and culture, resisted Meeker's efforts. In the late summer of 1879 some of the tribe's hunters left the reservation for a buffalo hunt. Meeker considered this a flagrant violation of agency rules and then repeated his demand that the band kill some of their horses^[2] and ordered their race track plowed under. Tempers flared, culminating in a brief but portentous shoving match or fist fight between the Ute medicine man Canalla and Meeker.^[3] Meeker reacted by wiring Department of Interior superiors for assistance. The Department, having no enforcement power, then contacted the War Department and no less a person than General William Tecumseh Sherman for federal troops to quell what he considered to be the initiation of an Indian uprising.

Battle

Opening of hostilities

Chief Ouray and Chipeta, sometime between 1865 and 1880

Orders descended from General Sherman in Washington to General Philip Sheridan in Chicago to General George Crook in Omaha to send a force expeditiously to aid Meeker.

Crook then forwarded orders to Major Thomas Tipton Thornburgh, a West Point graduate and Civil War officer stationed at Fort Steele, located near present-day Rawlins, Wyoming.^[4] On September 21, 1879, Major Thornburgh set out from Fort Steele with a force consisting of Company E, 3rd Cavalry; D and F Companies, 5th Cavalry; and Company B from Thornburgh's own 4th Infantry.^[5] The column had about 175 men, 25 supply wagons and pack mules.^[5][6] They proceeded toward the White River agency, over 180 miles distant, while sending reports back to General George Crook.

By September 25, Major Thornburgh, having been given only the vaguest of orders and possessing an equally imprecise knowledge of the situation at the agency, dispatched a message to Meeker informing him of the column's location and requesting Meeker meet him on the trail for a strategy session. On or about this same date cavalry outriders reported seeing mounted Ute warriors in the distance: the buffalo hunters under Nicaagat, or Jack, a young part-Apache sub-chief at the agency who had been raised by Mormons and served as a scout under General Crook.

Eventually, Jack and some of his men approached Thornburgh and asked where the column was headed. When told it was headed to the agency, the tribesmen sullenly departed, only to return that night and inform the Major that to do so would be a treaty violation. Instead Jack suggested a combined party of five Utes and five officers ride to the agency for a meeting with Meeker. Fearing a trap, Thornburgh declined. Ironically, Meeker, in a last-ditch attempt to head off the looming catastrophe, had dispatched a rambling letter to Thornburgh requesting, as Jack had wanted, that Thornburgh halt his column outside the reservation and proceed to the agency with a small number for a peace conference.^[7] Thornburgh then provided a no less murky response, written and verbal, the latter leading the Indians to conclude he was moving forward with his entire command. Thornburgh’s scout, Joe Rankin, reported seeing about twenty-five mounted warriors on the ridge in front of the column where the road crests a pass and dips into Coal Creek Canyon, an excellent place for an ambush.

Unknown to Thornburgh, his response to Meeker and subsequent actions had panicked the Utes at the agency, who remembered all too clearly the 1864 Sand Creek Massacre. They immediately assembled a fighting force of 200 to 300 warriors, mounted and afoot, armed with a wide variety of weapons. On September 28, more messages and warnings were sent and received by all three parties. Communication was chaotic and events had taken on a life of their own.

On September 29, Thornburgh led his column spearheaded by two companies, one from the 5th Cavalry and one from the 3rd Cavalry, two miles ahead of the wagon train of supplies and infantry with another company of cavalry in a distant reserve position. He approached Milk Creek, a thick, meandering alkali slough slicing an arroyo through a terraced, mile-wide park bordered by steep ridges covered with pine, cedar, oak brush and sage. This, in fact, was the point of no return. They were about fifteen miles from the agency and, to the Utes, clearly in violation of the treaty provisions. Concealed by the ridges, brush and trees, they had dispersed and waited.

Tension within Thornburgh’s ranks was palpable with many of the soldiers probably remembering the Little Bighorn disaster just three years earlier. Because the expedition was not to be construed as offensive, the men were issued only forty rounds of ammunition. A reconnaissance team comprising about four officers including Major Thornburgh and two scouts probed cautiously toward the crest of Yellow Jacket Pass, seeing as they proceeded mounted warriors passing back and forth along its crest. At almost exactly twelve o'clock noon, Lt. Samuel A. Cherry waved his hat either in peaceful greeting to the Utes or to signal Major Thornburgh. A shot rent the still mountain air followed by a brief silence and then fusillades from both sides.

Siege

General Wesley Merritt, circa 1865

Though the battle lasted for nearly a week, the stage was set for the duration within the first two hours with the Utes racing to out flank and segment the column and the soldiers struggling to consolidate a defense. Because neither side expected a battle, neither had developed effective strategies or tactics. The Indians thought that blocking the soldiers at the reservation boundary would cause them to reverse direction and go home.^[8] Thornburgh, perhaps because of muddled communications, thought a show of force on the Ute reservation would suppress any burgeoning uprising. The Ute chief Colorow has been documented as commenting at the time that a key objective was to capture the wagons containing the food supply, which would sustain the Indians and starve the soldiers into a retreat as opposed to retribution and annihilation. Even Jack, standing on a hillside and smoking his pipe while watching the battle unravel, pondered its suddenness and complete lack of a tactical objective other than halting the troop train.^[9] But if retreat was the overall Ute strategy they were quickly defeating that purpose by the tactic of killing all the cavalry horses and draft animals and unleashing such a hail storm of bullets that it provided the soldiers no opportunity for a fighting withdrawal.

Thornburgh, dashing about organizing a defensible position with wagons, animals and infantry on an adobe bench one hundred yards above Milk Creek, fell mortally wounded from a bullet to his chest. The battle was less than an hour old. Command passed to the wounded Captain Scott J. Payne, who tried to pass it on to Captain Lawson, the latter refusing and saying that Payne was still able to command. Within hours of the first shot fired at Milk Creek, the Utes remaining at the White River agency received word of the battle and ran amok killing and burning, sealing their fate.

Virtually all of the expedition's deaths happened before 5:30 on the evening of September 29, when the foundations of the defenses were established. At that time those defenses consisted of a circle of remaining wagons within which 150 defenders had dug another circle of seventeen trenches each two to four feet deep and approximately seventy-five feet long. These revetments were reinforced with dead animals, and with boxes and sacks from the wagons. The column had 127 mules and 183 horses.^[10] From the first volleys the animals had been targeted by the Indians, and at the end of the first day's fighting many horses and mules were dead. The Ute sharpshooters aimed to wound many of the animals inside the enclosure so their agony and stampeding would cause even more chaos and injury among the troops. Those deaths coupled with the humans killed in action inadvertently provided the Utes one of their next hopeful tactics: capitulation by gasification.

Rescue

However, the Utes had incompletely surrounded the trapped soldiers and during the night couriers were dispatched north for reinforcements, which arrived three days later in the form of Captain Francis Dodge and thirty-five men of D Company, 9th Cavalry, plus two civilians. Though hailed by the besieged as saviors, the men of the 9th Cavalry simply joined in the siege with food and ammunition.

On October 5, twenty officers and 234 men^[11] of the 5th Cavalry arrived, led by Colonel Wesley Merritt, having made a forced march of 170 miles from Fort D.A. Russell. Chief Jack, realizing no good purpose could be served by continuing the engagement, surrendered, using a piece of white tent canvas.

Aftermath

Ultimately, the army failed to prevent the Meeker massacre and the Utes lost their horses and lush mountain reservation and in 1881 were relocated west to the Utah desert. The army and militiamen lost thirteen dead and forty-four wounded, most of them in the first twenty-four hours of the engagement. Eleven soldiers were awarded the Medal of Honor and approximately thirty were decorated for heroic conduct in one of the most decorated battles of the Indian wars.^[12] Chief Jack estimated that nineteen Ute warriors were killed and seven were unaccounted for,^[13] though other sources say the Utes lost thirty-seven killed in both the Meeker incident and the battle.^[14][15][16]

References

1. "Milk Creek Battlefield Park". RioBlancoCounty.org. Rio Blanco County Historical Society & White River Museum. Retrieved 16 August 2016.
2. Sprague, Marshall, Massacre: The Tragedy At White River, University of Nebraska Press, 1957, p. 176
3. Marsh, Charles S., People of the Shining Mountains, Pruett Publishing Company, Boulder, Colorado, 1982, p. 90
4. Miller, Mark E., Hollow Victory, 1997, University Press of Colorado, Niwot, Colorado, p. 22
5. "Captain Dodge's Colored Troops to the Rescue". Retrieved 11 October 2013.
6. Miller, Mark E., Hollow Victory, 1997, University Press of Colorado, Niwot, Colorado, p. 22
7. Miller, pp. 43-44
8. Marsh, Charles F., People of the Shining Mountains, Pruett Publishing Company, Boulder, Colorado, p. 95.
9. Miller, p. 61
10. Miller, pp. 176–185
11. Miller, pp. 127–128
12. Miller, p. 181
13. "Unearthing the Battle of Milk Creek: September 29 - October 5, 1879 (9780615176222): Brad Edwards: Books". Amazon.com. Retrieved 2012-03-01.
14. "CGSC - Command and General Staff College". Cgsc.edu. Retrieved 2012-03-01.
15. Miller, p. 176
16. Miller, Mark E, Hollow Victory, University Press of Colorado, 1997

Coordinates: 40°12′6″N 107°41′25″W / 40.20167°N 107.69028°W